Netflix’s hit crime drama A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder has achieved a rare streaming milestone with its second season. The show has secured a near-perfect audience score on Rotten Tomatoes, marking a massive creative turnaround for the franchise.
The series is adapted from Holly Jackson’s bestselling young adult mystery novels and has rapidly gained global traction since returning to the streaming platform. Season two currently holds an impressive 96% audience score based on hundreds of user reviews, establishing it as one of the highest-rated Netflix crime releases of 2026.
This critical rebound is particularly notable given the mixed reception of the debut season, which walked away with a much lower 68% audience rating. While the first installment faced criticism regarding its pacing and book-to-screen adaptation choices, viewers are heavily praising the new episodes for delivering sharper storytelling and deeper character development.
FANS AND CRITICS UNITE IN PRAISE
Audience responses to the new mystery have been overwhelmingly positive. Dedicated fans have flooded review platforms to call the new season significantly better than the first, with many stating that the production has finally delivered the faithful adaptation they wanted.
Professional critics are also mirroring the enthusiasm of the fanbase. Reviewers have awarded the sophomore season a strong 86% critical approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a major step up from the previous year.
A significant portion of the acclaim centers on rising star Emma Myers, who anchors the series as the determined protagonist Pip Fitz-Amobi. Her performance is being widely celebrated as the emotional core of the entire show. Critics note that while the central mystery surrounding the disappearance of Jamie Reynolds drives the plot forward, it is Myers’ acting that elevates the emotional stakes.
EMMA MYERS SOLIDIFIES NETFLIX STARDOM
Myers, who first found global fame playing the colorful werewolf Enid Sinclair in the smash-hit series Wednesday, continues to solidify her position as one of Netflix’s most valuable leading actors.
Her Hollywood star power is expected to rise even further with several high-profile projects on the horizon. The actress is already attached to upcoming cinematic releases, including The Angry Birds Movie 3 and a sequel to A Minecraft Movie.
With its exceptional audience reception and powerful streaming numbers, the second season of A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder has officially cemented itself as one of the definitive young adult television successes of the year.
